Josiah M. Clokey purchased the property at 412 W. Prairie St. in 1881. He broke ground on the new residence in August of 1888. The main entrance was on the East front. On the first floor there was a reception room, a parlor, sitting room, dining room, kitchen, china closet and pantry. The second floor was an open space/hallway and five bed chambers. The cost of the house was approximately $10,000.
Mr. Clokey and his family moved into the house in the fall of 1889, despite the house not being finished. The original estimate was $8,000, which turned in to $10,000 and ended up at $13,000.
In February of 1898 he traded the residence on W.
Prairie and some other city property for a farm in Henry County. The trade was made with Louis E. Brown of Tazwell
County. Mr. Clokey gave his residence,
five lots in East Park Boulevard and 41 lots in Urban Place for a 1,163 acre
farm in Henry County located seven miles from Genesee. Mr. Clokey remained in the house a short time after the trade and rented from Mr. Brown.
In July of 1898 John H. Culver traded his house on N. Edward St., along with some other holdings, with L. E. Brown for the former Clokey house. He make extensive improvements to the property.
In July of 1898 John H. Culver traded his house on N. Edward St., along with some other holdings, with L. E. Brown for the former Clokey house. He make extensive improvements to the property which were designed by architect B. O. Rosen. The porch was re-designed to cover just the front of the house with a separate small porch on Edward St. Bedford stone lintels were placed above the windows and a ballroom was added to make the house three stories. The sitting room became John's library. He owned over 1,000 books at that time. The reception hall was divided to make a parlor and sitting room.
John and Florence Culver, along with their two daughters Elizabeth and Ruth, moved into the house in November of 1899.
A fire broke out in a 3rd floor apartment in May of 1979. The cause was determined to be a faulty extension cord. The Zuege's received money from the insurance company and took out a loan to do repairs. They made it eight apartments, and did the repairs as inexpensive as they could. The 3rd floor was left unfinished and a flat roof was put on.
In January of 1981 the apartments were again ready for occupancy.
Barbara Zuege obtained ownership of the apartments after their divorce. She did not keep up with the repairs of the Section 8 apartments. There were numerous city code violations. The house was eventually shut down by the city and boarded up.
During the vacancy, there were homeless people and drug addicts who spent time in the house.
In November of 1992, HUD inspected the house but could not do anything because they did not have a clear title to the house due to Mrs. Zuege not signing some paperwork. The city had a demolition order, but nothing could be done until there was a clear title.
Once HUD obtained the rights to the house, they sold it at auction. Steven Luker, the new owner, began working on the house, but was stopped by the city for not obtaining a work permit. He also had to follow codes for the historic district. He had not been told about the demo order, so he was given time to bring the house up to code. However, he did nothing for three years. In May of 1997, the city posted that the house was abandoned, unsafe, and would be demolished.